History of the Church
 

 
 

Background of the Church - History

An anchor in largely African-American North Philadelphia, the first Episcopal Church in the world to ordain women, the George W. South Memorial Church of the Advocate is a landmark in the religious, social and architectural history of the United States. Built as a memorial to the merchant and civil leader George W. South, the church was the centerpiece of a sprawling complex including a chapel, parish house, curacy and rectory. Once intended to serve as the Episcopal Cathedral of Philadelphia, The Church of the Advocate is one of the best American examples of Gothic Revival style and the only major one of its period based systematically on French sources.

No other church in America has been built in such a grand scale specifically for the working class. Also, none offers such a comprehensive repertoire of the Gothic Revival architecture: complete programs of lavish architectural sculpture; stained glass windows by Clayton & Bell, one of the leading English firms of the period; a full apparatus of flying buttresses and an orientation to the true East. The church demonstrates the Ruskinian doctrine of involving workmen in the design process, echoing the socially progressive programs that are part of the Advocate’s history and in contrast to the industrial, mechanized age in which it was created.

The Church’s Architect


The Church’s Architect, Charles Burns, is recognized as one of the most prominent church architects in the late 19th and early 20th century. His work includes over 50 churches some of which are the Church of the Savior, now the Episcopal Cathedral of Philadelphia; Church of The Redeemer, Bryn Mawr; Christ Church Cathedral, Salina, Kansas; and Calvary Church, Sioux Falls, South Dakota and the Union League of Philadelphia’s prominent clubhouse in Center City Philadelphia.

The Church of the Advocate and the Civil Rights Movement

The socially-conscious goals of the Church of the Advocate’s founders, who specified that the church should be “free for all time” (abolishing the practice of pew rent) continue. The Advocate became a center of activism for the Civil Rights Movement embracing the cause of African-American and women’s rights. It was the site of several nationally significant events of these movements including the National Conference of Black Power (1968), the Black Panther Conference (1970) and the first ordination of women in the Episcopal Church (1974).
An inspiring collection of large and vivid wall murals commissioned in the 1970's records the “stations” of the Civil Rights movement. As in medieval churches, whose art served to illustrate and reinforce this liturgical message, these murals draw on Old Testament verses to dramatically illuminate parallels in African American history. Together, the medieval revival presentation of the building and the modern murals document the critical social role played by America’s inner city churches.

Reverend Paul Washington’s leadership allowed the church to support rights rallies and protests and also developed what he came to call the Theology of Black Power. He believed that God intended all people, regardless of their race and color, to be vessels of divine power.

The interpretation of this history continues as the church is part of a tour on the History of the Civil Rights Movement which is presented by the Greater Philadelphia Tourism and Marketing Corporation as well as a stop on various other tours through the year.

In addition to hosting these events, a collection of wall murals commissioned by Reverend Washington records the “stations” of the Civil Rights movement. These murals were created between 1973 and 1976 by Walter Edmonds and Richard Watson, who to this day enjoy coming to explain to visitors the story of their murals. These impressive and often contentious “art of protest” murals were inspired by Bible passages; they compare the oppression experienced by the Jewish people during their enslavement and captivity and African American oppression and response to it in American history. The murals are arranged in a traditional biblical cycle and culminate with the “I Have A Dream” speech of Martin Luther King, Jr. One can find portrayed in the murals a wide range of African American leaders and others who fought for the freedoms of African Americans including Toussaint L’Overture, Harriet Tubman, Booker T. Washington, Julian Bond, W.E. B. Dubois, Paul Robeson, and Malcolm X. As in medieval churches, whose art served to illustrate and reinforce the liturgical message, these modern murals address the contemporary concerns of the church’s congregation and allow dialogue among the races and socio-economic classes today.

The Church and the History of Women

The Church played a key role in women’s and religious history as the site of the “irregular” ordinations as priest of the first group of 11 women in the Episcopal Church in 1974. Prior to the ceremony the parish approved the following statement: “The goals of the Advocate have always been to move towards one world, one people, and one love concept. We are not afraid to take any step or measure that will make that concept a reality.” Within two years the Episcopal Church officially authorized the ordination of women.

 

Kudos for the Church of the Advocate's History

The Church of the Advocate has been receiving praise and awards for its architecture and history since it was founded. 

  • National Historic Landmark (1996)

This recognition is determined by the United States Secretary of Interior for buildings that are nationally significant in American history.  The Church of the Advocate shares this distinction with some of the nation's most important historic properties including Mount Vernon, Pearl Harbor, and the Martin Luther King Birthplace.  National Historic Landmark status is the most prestigious recognition that a historic site can achieve in the United States.

  • Save America's Treasures Grant (2005)

The Church of the Advocate was awarded a Save America's Treasures grant based on its historic significance.  This highly-competitive prestigious award has provided $500,000 toward much needed repairs to the exterior of the building.

  • National Register of Historic Places (1980)

This list is the nation's official list of districts, sites, buildings, structures and objects worthy of preservation.  The Church of the Advocate achieved this status by meeting the four criteria required for the Register – contribution to American history, association with significant people, distinctive architecture and construction, and the ability to serve as an educational site about history.

  • Pennsylvania Inventory of Historic Places (1979)
    This is the highest recognition the state provides for historic sites.
  • Philadelphia Historic Commission – Philadelphia Register of Historic Places (1980)

This is the highest recognition the city provides for historic sites.  The Church of the Advocate is also considered a key site in the Diamond Street Historic District.

  • Landmark Building Award, Philadelphia Chapter AIA (1985)
  • King's Handbook of Episcopalian Churches, a register of the most prominent Episcopal building in the country, listed the advocate when it was still being built in 1889.

Roger Moss in Historic Sacred Places of Philadelphia (University of Pennsylvania Press, 2005) wrote that "The Church of the Advocate is one of the principal monuments of the Gothic Revival in the United States, and the only major one of its period based systematically on French sources. It is loosely based on thirteenth-century French churches, particularly the small Gothic cathedrals marked with enormous rose windows.   The Church of the Advocate is nothing less than a quadripartite, stone-vaulted French medieval Gothic church dropped in to a North Philadelphia neighborhood that is now physically and economically devastated."  

Although all of the work of the church architect's Charles Burn is important, Roger Moss tells us that it is believed that if Burns "designed but one church in the late nineteenth century, The George W. South Memorial Protestant Episcopal Church of the Advocate would sustain his reputation."